Putting Together the CMB-S4 Science Book Requirements Table

From CMB-S4 wiki
Revision as of 14:00, 19 December 2016 by Tcrawfor (talk | contribs) (→‎NEUTRINOS)
Jump to navigationJump to search

The Concept Definition Task Force has been tasked with writing down science requirements, with three suggested levels (sky's the limit, minimum worth doing, something in between). John C. has, in turn, asked the Science Book chapter leads to create a summary table of requirements from the book. Below are notes and discussions for each Science Book "science goal" chapter (intro, CMB lensing, and analysis/sims/forecasting not included). Chapter leads are particularly encouraged to contribute material and collate into a final recommendation. As per John C.'s email (and the recommendation of Jo Dunkley and others to the CDT), there is also an "astrophysics chapter" included in the discussions.


From Raphael:

Theorist’s dream: σ(r)=1×10−6

Aspirational goal: σ(r)=5×10−4

Minimal goal: σ(r)=1×10−3

Both are for a fiducial value of r = 0 and must include foreground removal and systematics.


From Raphael:

Theorist’s dream: σ(\sum mν)=8meV

Aspirational goal: σ(\sum mν)=15meV

Minimal goal: σ(\sum mν)=20meV

Both are for a normal mass hierarchy with \sum mν = 58 meV, rely on the lensing power spectrum, and include a prior from DESI BAO measurements and assume an external measurement of the optical depth with σ(τ) = 0.006.





From Raphael:

One area not covered by these requirements is cluster science. No clear targets were identified in the science book, but it is qualitatively clear that cluster science significantly benefits from higher resolution. For example at ”a 99% purity threshold, the 3, 2 and 1 arc- minute configurations would identify approximately 45,000, 70,000 and 140,000 clusters.” Furthermore, at 1 arcmin resolution one could begin to resolve clusters and study pressure profiles, learn about baryonic physics, etc. Clusters can also be used to constrain neutrino mass. To my knowledge sufficiently reliable forecasts for this do not exist.