LBNL-2016: Foregrounds for Inflation and Lensing

From CMB-S4 wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search

The purpose of this session is to discuss the astrophysical foregrounds that could bias or contaminate measurements for inflation and lensing.

Those agreeing to present should not prepare full-blown talks, but rather a slide or two with some ideas that will foment discussion.


Foregrounds - Inflation:

  • Foreground residuals: how do we model those at this moment?
    • Josquin
  • Astrophysics: What do we know today and what remains uncertain about the diffuse galactic foregrounds?
  • Foreground modeling:
    • Alex, Ben and Flavien

[ for discussion: ]

  • Forecast validation: What is the role of map-level simulations and data challenges in validating forecasting efforts, which presumably will use various approaches to component separation?
    • AGREED: all sigma(r) forecasting needs to explicitly include FG separation, AND needs to be validated with map-space sims using diffuse FG sky models.
      • Both spectral and pixel-space component separation can be Fisherized, but BOTH can also be validated with map-space sims and biases from residuals quantified.

  • Band Selection: What is the plan to study how FG complexity feeds into band selection, and may indicate different optimizations for different kinds of S4 survey.
    • CHARGE FOR TOMORROW's sky modeling session: We need an ensemble of FG sky models (multiple realizations, several stages of complexity)
      • this ensemble needs to be agreed as a standard test set for various sigma(r) forecast efforts
      • need first set by ~May
      • we can expect future versions, updated with more sophisticated physics and better (S3) data

Kam: What format? Maps every 10 GHz? Or tools for which bandpasses can be specified?

Charles: realistic BPs must be included.

Lyman: use Planck as worked example of what level of FG residual did they stop using for parameter estimation.

Foregrounds - Lensing:

9:45 Alexander van Engelen - how foregrounds bias lensing measurements (5+5)

9:55 Blake Sherwin - quantifying and mitigating foreground bias (5+5)

Plenary Summary